Herod was first seen when the three wise men and their camels named Felix, Cyrus and Deborah, arrive at his palace. The wise men revealed their gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh, but when they reveal that it is for the "new King", he sends them on their way to meet him and give him his blessing.
However, as the three wise men leave, Herod secretly sends the Hunter and his two dogs Thaddeus and Rufus to find and kill the newborn, believing that the newborn might threaten his legacy as a great ruler; even Felix, Cyrus and Deborah overheard this and decided to ensure that Herod's plan must be stopped at all costs.
The Hunter and his dogs tracked Mary and Joseph across the country, eventually finding them in Bethlehem. Before the Hunter could accomplish the goal, the couple's pet donkey Bo gets the camels and a flock of sheep to attack the Hunter and the dogs, sending them hanging for life on the edge of a cliff. The Hunter attempts to drop both Thaddeus and Rufus to save his own skin, but Bo rescues them while the Hunter ends up falling to his death, leaving Herod's plans in vain.
During the credits, Thaddeus and Rufus are shown rejecting, betraying, and arresting Herod after their rehabilitation, seeing now that he was only using them. It is unknown what happened to Herod afterwards as he was never mentioned again. However, in Biblical canon, Herod died just a few years later.
- Despite only having 10 minutes of screentime, Herod served as the Heavy and Bigger Bad because he was the mastermind behind the plot to kill the newborn Jesus. Plus, the Hunter was carrying out his orders and do anything to make his plans would succeed.